Five in the Family, Four Keys—I'm Done Being the Unfavorite
Chapter 1
The day we moved into the new house, everyone got a key. Except me.
When I asked, my mom just smiled. "Just ring the bell. Someone will let you in."
I said okay. Maybe if I was good enough, they'd notice me.
Then I got accepted to the state's only full scholarship abroad.
My passport was locked in my room.
And the application deadline was in a few hours.
I got home at noon. Door locked, nobody there.
I called my mom. She was shopping with my sister.
I called my dad. He was with my brother.
No one came back.
By the time they finally returned, it was too late.
They didn't even ask why I was sitting on the floor outside all day.
That night I dragged my suitcase out from under the bed.
There were four keys in that house.
One for each of them. Just not for me.
Fine. I'll build my own house then.
...
"Zoey, did you submit that application or not?"
Mom sat across from me at dinner, pushing the chicken platter toward my sister Elena.
Three days. It had been three days since I sat on that hallway floor for eight hours.
"Didn't make it."
"What?" She paused. "Why didn't you ask for an extension?"
"Deadlines are deadlines."
"God, Zoey. You're so rigid." She shook her head, turned to Elena. "Eat more, sweetie. You're too thin."
Elena bit into the chicken, then looked at me. "Was it important?"
I looked at her. Fifteen years old. Red marks on her face from piano practice.
Her tone like asking about the weather.
"Yeah. It was."
Nothing to them. Everything to me.
The only state-funded scholarship abroad.
Three thousand students competing.
Recommendation from the department chair himself.
My brother Jace walked in wearing brand-new headphones, dropped into his seat.
"Mom, I need another driving lesson tomorrow. Venmo me."
"How much?"
"Eight hundred."
Mom pulled out her phone instantly.
Eight hundred bucks.
My application fee was three-twenty.
Last month I asked Mom for it. She said after payday.
By deadline? She'd forgotten. She was buying Elena dresses.
"Zoey, dishes."
Dad walked past with his coffee, dropped onto the couch scrolling his phone.
I stared at four people's plates.
Jace's plate still had food smeared everywhere.
Elena's was clean, but chicken bones scattered across the table.
"Dad. That scholarship's gone."
Dad's eyes flicked up for half a second. Then back to his phone.
"Well. It is what it is. Not your only option."
It is what it is.
He didn't even ask why.
Didn't want to know I sat on cold concrete until my knees went numb.
Just done.
While washing dishes, Mom came in for water.
"Zoey, Saturday take Elena to get her piano tuned. Your dad and I are taking Jace to a car show."
"Can't she go herself?"
"Does she even know how? Remember when she got on the wrong bus?"
Elena was fifteen. She'd competed at twenty venues across the city.
Getting on the wrong bus happened when she was nine.
Mom remembered that for six years.
But when I ended up in the ER with an allergic reaction?
Next day she forgot which room.
"Fine."
I shut off the water. Stacked the dishes.
Back in my room I locked the door.
That suitcase still under the bed, clothes already packed.
My phone buzzed. Class group chat. Message from our teacher.
"Congratulations to Zoey Whitman for receiving this year's state scholarship recommendation!
Although personal circumstances prevented submission, her achievements speak for themselves."
I stared at it. Forwarded it to the family chat.
Nobody replied.
Twenty minutes later, Elena sent a voice message:
"Mom, I wanna wear my blue hoodie tomorrow. Did you wash it?"
Mom replied instantly: "Already done!"
I exited the chat. Turned off my phone.
I folded that scholarship notice and tucked it in my journal.
Wouldn't need it anymore.
But I was keeping it.
To remind myself this family owed me more than just a key.
When I was thirteen, Elena won first place at regionals. Mom posted nine pictures on Instagram.
Same day, my essay got published in a state journal.
I showed Mom the copy. She goes, "Set it down. I'll look later."
Her "later" never came.
Three months after that, Elena used it as scratch paper.
Mom said, "No big deal. Get another copy."
That day I wrote on the first page of my journal:
"If I disappeared, how long would it take them to notice?"
At thirteen, I didn't know.
At eighteen, I did.
Chapter 2
"Zoey, come here."
Saturday morning. Dad was actually in the living room for once, bank statement spread out in front of him.
I thought maybe he was finally giving me that three-twenty.
Last month Mom said end of the month. Now it was next month.
"Look at this."
Dad pushed the statement toward me, finger on a withdrawal line.
"Last month on the twentieth. Did you pull cash from the family account?"
I glanced at the amount. Three hundred sixty.
"No."
"Then who? Only you three know the PIN."
"Jace and Elena know it too."
Dad shook his head. That look like he'd already decided, just needed me to confess.
"Jace was at the DMV that day. Elena was at the piano shop with your mom."
"You called in sick. Stayed home. Right?"
I did stay home.
Because the night before I'd spiked a 102° fever and dragged myself to urgent care. Next day my head was still splitting.
But in this house? Calling in sick just made you suspicious.
"You were home. Money went missing. I'm not accusing you. Just asking."
Worse than accusing me outright.
No clear thing to fight back against, but I was already nailed down as guilty.
"Dad, it wasn't me. Check the ATM footage. There's cameras."
"Is that really necessary? Security tapes on our own family?"
He folded up the statement. Sighed.
"Forget it. If you needed it, fine. Just tell us next time."
Just like that.
No evidence. No investigation. No clearing my name.
Because I was the easiest one to blame.
At lunch, Mom suddenly said:
"Zoey, your dad told you about the money?"
"Yeah. Wasn't me."
"Doesn't matter. We'll just change the PIN."
Jace walked in. "What PIN?"
Mom said, "I'll tell you later."
He shrugged. Sat down.
I noticed his shoes.
White. Fat logo on the side. Exactly like the ones he'd been begging for last week.
I'd seen them online. Three hundred sixty bucks.
I said nothing.
Because in this house, Jace buying shoes was normal.
Me "stealing money" was reasonable doubt.
Even though the timeline matched perfectly.
Even though he was literally wearing the evidence.
That afternoon taking Elena to tune her piano, she tugged my sleeve on the bus.
"Zoey... about that money..."
Her voice dropped. Eyes darting.
"I saw Jace coming out of Mom and Dad's room that day. He had his phone out. Doing a transfer."
I looked at her. "Did you tell them?"
She shook her head. Lips pressed together. "Even if I did, they wouldn't believe me."
See? Even a fifteen-year-old knew the rules.
Speaking up for me was pointless.
"It's fine," I said.
At the shop, the tuner worked on Elena's piano.
She sat nearby swinging her legs.
"Zoey, are you mad?"
"No."
"You always say no when you're the most mad."
I turned toward the window. Said nothing.
Back home, there was an opened package on the entry table. Jace's name on it.
Sports watch inside. Price sticker still on. Two hundred forty.
Add the shoes. Three-sixty plus two-forty. Six hundred total.
Family account missing three-sixty. My brother spent six hundred.
The difference? Obviously Mom covered it.
I opened my banking app. Checked my balance.
Twenty-two hundred dollars.
Every penny I'd saved. Whole summer working.
Subtract a plane ticket. Subtract first month's rent somewhere new. Enough for two weeks.
What happened after two weeks? I hadn't figured that out yet.
But I knew one thing.
Staying here? I wouldn't last two weeks.
That night lying in bed, I heard laughter from the living room.
Jace showing Mom his new watch. Mom saying "that's so cool."
Dad teasing Elena. Asking her to play something new.
Piano music drifted in. Soft. Complete. Like a bubble with no cracks.
I was outside that bubble.
Could see the light. Couldn't get in.
I opened my phone. Posted online: "How do you start over from zero?"
Hundreds of replies. Every single one saying the same thing.
Leaving is hard. Staying is harder.
Chapter 3
"Ms. Carter, we need to see you at school this week."
Homeroom teacher called three times. Nobody picked up the first two.
Third time, Mom answered.
That night she pulled me into the living room. Face like stone.
"Your teacher says you're zoning out in class. You're ranked thirty-seventh now?"
"Yeah."
"Are you SERIOUS? You used to be top ten. What the hell happened?"
Before? I didn't spend my nights washing everyone's dishes.
Didn't play chauffeur for Elena's piano lessons.
Didn't get blamed when money went missing.
Didn't drag myself to urgent care alone burning with fever.
Before, my time was actually mine.
Now everyone just took pieces whenever they wanted.
"I'm just struggling."
"Struggling? Elena practices four hours a day and STILL gets straight A's."
"You don't practice anything. Don't compete. Just study. And THIS is what you pull?"
But Elena had her own room. Her own schedule. Nobody touched her routine.
Me?
My to-do list before "study": dishes, vacuum, pick up sister, errands for brother.
I met her eyes. "Teacher wants to meet Saturday."
Mom sighed hard. "Me AGAIN?"
"You or Dad."
"Your dad's swamped all week."
She pressed her fingers to her temples.
"Fine. I'll reschedule Elena's lesson. Saturday morning."
Wait. She was actually coming?
Something small and warm flickered in my chest.
"...Thanks, Mom."
She waved it off. "Just fix your grades. Don't make us look bad."
Saturday morning. School gate. Two hours waiting.
Mom never showed.
I called. Mall noise blaring behind her voice.
"Oh honey, Elena's teacher just texted—there's this master class today. Total last minute. Can't pass it up."
"We're already here. Just tell your teacher we'll come another time."
I stood there. Phone pressed to my ear.
Sun beating down. Shadow pooling small and dark at my feet.
"Okay."
"Love you. Go home and study hard, sweetie."
Click. She hung up fast.
My teacher was watching from her office window. Glasses catching the light.
I climbed the stairs. Knocked.
She didn't mention my missing parent. Just slid a form across her desk.
"National essay competition. Cash prize for first place. I've read your work. You should enter."
I looked at the paper. "Registration fee..."
"School's got it covered."
I nodded. Folded the form into my pocket.
Home. Shopping bags covering every surface.
Elena spinning in front of the mirror in a new leotard.
Jace face-down on the couch scrolling.
Mom crouched over an open shoebox.
"These are softer. Try them on."
Elena slipped into the ballet flats. Took two steps. Made a face. "Too tight."
"We'll swap them tomorrow. Zoey, you'll take her."
"I've got a competition deadline tomorrow."
"Can't you just write on your phone on the way?"
"Fifteen hundred words. On my phone?"
Mom looked up. Like I was being deliberately difficult.
"Can you PLEASE just help for once? Elena needs those shoes for competition next week."
Same story every time.
HER competition. HER costume. HER piano. HER everything.
Mine? Whatever didn't fit got shoved aside.
I didn't fight. Went to my room.
Laptop open. Wrote until my vision blurred. 1 AM before I stopped.
Next morning dragged myself out on three hours of sleep. Dark circles like bruises.
Took Elena downtown to exchange shoes.
Subway ride back, she said, "Zoey, your eyes look bad."
"Didn't sleep much."
"Were you writing? I heard your keyboard through the wall."
"Yeah. Competition piece."
Elena went quiet. Then tilted her head, studying me.
"You're really good at writing. I still remember that moon story from when I was little."
When she was seven years old. She was afraid of the dark.
I'd made up a whole story to calm her down.
She remembered.
"If you write something cool, you'll tell me, right?"
I looked at her.
The golden child everyone orbited around.
Only person in this house who ever asked if I was okay.
But her kindness was like candy.
Sweet for two seconds. Then gone. And the aftertaste stayed bitter.
That night. Ten minutes before deadline. I hit submit.
Living room, Mom blow-drying Elena's hair. Noise like a jet engine.
Jace button-mashing his controller. Game sounds blasting.
Nobody knew what I'd just finished.
Nobody asked.
...
"FIRST PLACE!"
My teacher slapped the notification down on her desk. Grinning wider than I'd ever seen.